I think that the recent case put to them that Trump has the power to sack formally independent institutional heads may be an answer. It certainly put Federal judges on notice. Not addressed directly, but once Trump sacks a Federal judge under that rulling the legal consequences for SCOTUS may be startling. He, or the next president may dump any or all of the Supremes that they don’t like?
Caveat: not a lawyer, or even close to being one. Just a long-time interested observer.
18 is probably correct number. Its the shortest even-numbered term that doesn’t allow a normal 2-term president to replace half the court. If you want to count the extreme case of a 10-year president due to a VeeP taking over then getting elected twice, it should be 20 years with terms starting on like January 10.
SCOTUS is flawed because it IS beholden to the other branches.
What I mean is, the President picks the nominee and Congress approves them. Every other branch is selected by the people.
It gives the other branches too much power over the judicial branch. It harms checks and balances.
It’s far worse than that. The judiciary is able to be fired by the executive branch and that simply should not be possible.
I feel the checks on the supreme court is close. I think with 18 year ish terms to replace 1 every every 2 years consistently would work
No it isn’t. Federal judges serve for life. They can’t be removed by the President
I think that the recent case put to them that Trump has the power to sack formally independent institutional heads may be an answer. It certainly put Federal judges on notice. Not addressed directly, but once Trump sacks a Federal judge under that rulling the legal consequences for SCOTUS may be startling. He, or the next president may dump any or all of the Supremes that they don’t like?
Caveat: not a lawyer, or even close to being one. Just a long-time interested observer.
18 is probably correct number. Its the shortest even-numbered term that doesn’t allow a normal 2-term president to replace half the court. If you want to count the extreme case of a 10-year president due to a VeeP taking over then getting elected twice, it should be 20 years with terms starting on like January 10.